Tesla Acquitted in Landmark Autopilot Liability Trial

Matt Brand
November 1, 2023
Buy a Car!
Find your perfect car with ease – click for a free, seamless journey with CarSauce and Motor Scout!

In a pivotal legal decision, Tesla has emerged victorious in a United States courtroom, successfully defending its Autopilot system against claims of causing a fatal accident - as reported by Reuters and other US publications.

This marks a significant win for the electric vehicle manufacturer amidst a series of lawsuits and federal probes into the technology.

The jury's decision, reached in a civil lawsuit at the Riverside County Superior Court, absolved Tesla's Autopilot system of any manufacturing defects in a crash that resulted in one fatality and severe injuries to two passengers. The incident, which occurred in 2019, involved a Model 3 that departed the roadway and collided with a palm tree at high speed.

Tesla Model 3 Crash during ANCAP Testing

Tesla contended that the driver, Micah Lee, had alcohol in his system and that it was uncertain whether the Autopilot was active at the crash time. The plaintiffs, seeking $400 million in damages, highlighted the severe injuries sustained by the passengers, including a young child.

After four days of deliberation, the 12-person jury, with a 9-3 vote, concluded that the vehicle was not defective. Despite the plaintiffs' legal team expressing disappointment, the verdict underscores the responsibility of drivers, even when advanced driver-assistance systems are in use.

Tesla maintains that its vehicles are safe and contribute to road safety, a stance bolstered by a previous trial win in Los Angeles. In that case, the jury agreed that Tesla had sufficiently warned drivers to monitor the Autopilot system actively.

Legal experts note that these verdicts reflect a societal expectation that drivers remain accountable for vehicle control. However, the Riverside case's focus on a potential manufacturing defect related to the vehicle's steering presented a unique challenge for the jury.

Tesla's stock saw an uptick following the verdict, and the company has taken steps to refine its Autopilot system, addressing potential issues identified in an internal safety analysis from 2017.

The automaker is still under scrutiny, with ongoing criminal and regulatory investigations into its driver-assistance systems. Nonetheless, industry analysts suggest that Tesla's legal defenses, bolstered by clear disclaimers, present a formidable challenge to liability claims.

In summary, Tesla's legal victory in the recent Autopilot case reaffirms the driver's responsibility in operating driver-assisted vehicles and may influence future litigation and regulatory actions in the evolving field of automotive technology.

Matt Brand
Matt Brand, the esteemed car critic from Car Sauce, offers unparalleled expertise on all things automotive. From new car releases to pre-owned options, he provides in-depth analysis and honest evaluations to guide readers through the car-buying process. Join us as he delves into the exciting world of motoring.

Other car news

Peugeot Australia Opens Pre-Orders for E-Expert Electric Van

Peugeot Australia now accepts pre-orders for the E-Expert electric van, with delivery starting in Q4 2024.
Matt Brand
May 21, 2024

Toyota Australia Resumes GR Yaris Orders and Implements New Allocation Policy

Toyota Australia resumes GR Yaris orders with a new "first in, first out" delivery policy for its GR models starting July.
Jacob Brooke
May 21, 2024

Jaecoo J7 PHEV Under Strong Consideration for Australia

Jaecoo J7 PHEV under consideration for Australia in late 2024. Potential powertrain offers 260 kW, 525 Nm, 4.1 L/100km, and 88km EV range.
Matt Brand
May 21, 2024

Sign up to our newsletter

Be the first to know when we drop new car reviews.

By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Welcome to the Car Sauce community!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.